Footy Games Comparison


 

This review is primarily concerned with footy games that you play. ie not football management type football games.

Games Reviewed (In order of greatness):

1.Microprose Soccer
2.Liverpool
3.Gary Lineker's Superstar Soccer
4.Emlyn Hughes



Microprose Soccer:

By far and away the greatest footy game on the C64. The pitch is viewed from above which isn't very realistic but allows for a very playable game. The players are nice and big and the "feel" of the game is superb. Includes action replays of goals which take this game into another dimension. Being able to see just how good a goal you slotted past your friend's pathetic keeper is sweet.

You can easily control the ball and predict what is going to happen unlike most footy games. You can pass the ball with some control, although this could be the game's weakpoint, and the bend function is outstanding and very useful. Bending around players (and goalkeepers) is a key element to succeeding in this game.

If all these features weren't enough, you have rain to contend with as well.... Watch in dispair as you use the sliding tackle and your defender spins off the screen like a spinning top...quality!

Indoor / Outdoor:

There are effectively 2 separate games in Microprose Soccer:
European (Outdoor)
Indoor

European is the main game and is played outdoors. Most of this review uses this game.
The Indoor game is a fast, manic indoor 6-a-side. Play this if you want to lose. Good fun although very difficult.

Scoring:

There are a many methods that you can use to score eg diagonal straight, diagonal with bend, straight with bend, bend from goal line, overhead kick, to name the obvious ones. The game is such that you can experiment and occasionally, new "lucky" goal scoring methods can be discovered like running the ball in or scoring via a sliding tackle. Variety is the key to this game. You do not simply point a player at the goal and shoot, hoping for the best.

Tournements:

Microprose Soccer gives you four tournements to compete in:
World Cup Tournement - 1 or 2 player league / knockout
Microprose International Challenge - 1 player ladder
Soccer League - league for multiple human players
2-Player Friendly

The world cup is the main part of the game, but the international challenge is a great idea in that you play a selection of teams, from worst to best in a football "ladder" enabling you to consistantly play against teams that match your ability.

The in-game music is outstanding as well. With a few seconds remaining in each half, or in extra time, the music changes to suit the mood. Just pray that your "golden goal" extra time period does not stretch into minutes as the pressure could become intolerable.....



Liverpool:

Liverpool is similar to Microprose Soccer with smaller players, faster action and some additional team selection stuff and english tournements. Gameplay is awful with lack of control a major problem. The team selection is particularly poor as you change the team, but do not know what position they will play. Also the location of players on the pitch leaves a lot to be desired, which makes passing very difficult.

And, of course, you have to play as Liverpool. Whilst this might be acceptable to Ealan, my partner in crime on this site, it is not a pleasant experience for myself. I know the game is called Liverpool but they could have given you a choice of teams.....


Rated highly by some but not by me.



Gary Lineker's Superstar Soccer:

Was a reasonable footy game until Microprose Soccer hit the scene. Wide choice of teams - you can choose any English or "American" league team. You can build up your team by trading, this feature was not in the tape version I grew up on, and this does increase the variantion in this game.

In game, you can pick players, make substitutions, change tactics. These are quite useful and add more variety to the game. The choice of teams is important as you can tailor the ability of the opposition to your own ability. Ie play with Tottenham against Bristol Rovers if you are just starting, or the other way round if you think you are any good. Be warned, keepers range from poor to transparent. This just adds to the fun, forcing you to attack more. Football played the old fashioned way with scores of 12-13 a regular occurance!

The game is viewed side on in a 3D sort of way and it is very easy to pass the ball as you can see enough of the pitch to enable you to do this. Unlike Microprose Soccer and Liverpool, when you pass the ball, it goes to the nearest player on your team, not the direction you are facing, which makes this game very playable but frustrating at the same time. Scream as you are about to pass the ball to an unmarked player in a scoring position and the ball goes to a player on the halfway line! Overhead kick is good fun. Scoring from the half way line is also good fun.

Ultimately, the lack of control over shooting,,you simply shoot and hope, lets this game down but it is still worth playing.




Emlyn Hughes

Simply a poor man's version of "Gary Linekar's Superstar Soccer". Do not play it.

The configuration menus are great and the first time you load the game you cannot fail to be impressed. The problem starts when you want to actually play football. The graphics are awful, gameplay is nonexistant - as slow as Gary Lineker's but at least you could pass the ball there. Why did they bother with the crowd sound effects...

Emyln Hughes suffers from the same scoring inadequacies as Gary Lineker's but at least you can vary the direction slightly.

This is a classic case of development budget being spent in the wrong areas. Why make the pre-game stuff look so good whilst the point of the excersise - playing footy - is so bad. Mutton dressed up as lamb. Damn right.



by Richard Mace 2000
 

C64 Home
Home